ITEN

Home › Articles › RAM prices: the cartel lawsuit against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron goes ahead, and the judge finds collusion plausible

RAM prices: the cartel lawsuit against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron goes ahead, and the judge finds collusion plausible

A California federal court has rejected the motion to dismiss the class action accusing the three manufacturers of jointly restricting the supply of conventional DRAM. It is not a conviction, but the case now moves into discovery.

Statcade graphic: RAM prices: the cartel lawsuit against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron goes ahead, and the judge finds collusion plausible
Image: Statcade graphic based on data from the Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics filings

The class action over DRAM memory prices against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron can proceed. Federal judge Noël Wise, of the Northern District of California, on 14 November denied the joint motion to dismiss filed by the three companies in Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics. It is a preliminary decision, which only assesses whether the allegations are plausible and establishes no liability.

The 17 plaintiffs, consumers and small businesses from five US states, claim that since October 2022 the three manufacturers, which together controlled over 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025, coordinated a reduction in the supply of conventional memory, with a price rise of 697% in 18 months according to the complaint.

In the order the judge gives weight to a series of behaviours: the staggered production cuts between late 2022 and April 2023, the “sudden, rapid, and coordinated exit” from DDR4, the long-term supply contracts reserved for artificial intelligence customers, Micron's closure of its consumer brand Crucial in December 2025 and almost identical customer verification procedures introduced by the three in January 2026. The companies had cited judge Richard Posner, according to whom competitors in concentrated markets “watch each other like hawks”; Wise replied that the allegations rather describe “hawks flying in formation, something hawks don't usually do”. The claims on DDR3 and those based on statements to investors and meetings at industry conferences were dismissed.

The companies must answer the complaint by 7 December; the first case management hearing is set for 12 January 2027. For anyone building a PC the matter is far from abstract: the rise in memory prices is today among the main causes of higher prices for PCs and components.

Sources: US District Court for the Northern District of California, order of 14 November 2026 in Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, reported by Chip Dispatch, Tom's Hardware, Chosun Biz and SamMobile (15–16 November 2026). Text by Statcade.

Support Statcade

If Statcade's data is useful to you, you can buy us a coffee on Ko-fi.

Buy us a coffee on Ko-fi (opens in a new tab)

The week’s numbers

One email a week, with video game numbers. No third-party promotions.

Sign-up is for people aged at least 14. We send you a confirmation email: you join the list only after you click the link.