ITEN

Home › Articles › Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition: critics approve but users revolt, with a user score of around 2 out of 10 on Metacritic

Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition: critics approve but users revolt, with a user score of around 2 out of 10 on Metacritic

A few days after launch, the Switch 2 edition of Pikmin 4 with Dandori Academy is receiving a flood of negative user scores on Metacritic, while critics rate it well. The complaints concern longer loading times, 30 frames per second and new levels that largely reuse those of the base game.

Statcade graphic: Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition: critics approve but users revolt, with a user score of around 2 out of 10 on Metacritic
Image: Statcade graphic based on data from OpenCritic, TheGamer and Kotaku

Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy came out on 12 November. It is the enhanced Switch 2 version of the 2023 game, also available as an upgrade for those who already own the Switch version. The critics' verdict is positive: OpenCritic shows an 84 average among top critics (17 November); on 16 November TheGamer reported 83 on Metacritic too. The Metacritic user score is very different. On 16 November TheGamer reported it at 1.8 out of 10 and, on the same day, Kotaku at 2.1 from 265 ratings. The original Pikmin 4 has a user score of 8.9.

The user reviews quoted by the two outlets repeat the same criticisms. On Switch 2 the game stays at 30 frames per second and according to some loading times are longer than in the original; neither outlet, however, measured loading times. Many also take issue with Dandori Academy, whose levels largely reuse base-game maps and are unlocked gradually. According to Nintendo's official page there are 72 levels in total, six a month, with exams on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays. On Reddit some also think the negative scores are exaggerated. Kotaku notes, however, that few openly defend the edition.

Even before the user protests, reviews had flagged the same limits: Nintendo Life gave it 7 out of 10, criticising the monthly level release and the absence of 60 frames per second. For Nintendo, Switch 2 editions are a way to bring the Switch catalogue back to market. Among those released so far, according to TheGamer, the protests against this one have been the strongest. At the time of writing there are no public comments from Nintendo.

Sources: TheGamer (16 November 2026); Kotaku (16 November 2026); Nintendo, official game page; OpenCritic (17 November 2026); Nintendo Life, review. Text by Statcade.

Support Statcade

If Statcade's data is useful to you, you can buy us a coffee on Ko-fi.

Buy us a coffee on Ko-fi (opens in a new tab)

The week’s numbers

One email a week, with video game numbers. No third-party promotions.

Sign-up is for people aged at least 14. We send you a confirmation email: you join the list only after you click the link.